^_^ I guess that since I'm traveling through the game at a snail's pace and because I haven't reunited with Asch since he left my party I'm speculating. At this point Guy hasn't said what his true feelings about Asch are but at this point he seems to be rejecting him as much as he accepts Luke. I'm just remembering a face chat I saw when I spent an extra night in Peony's palace where Guy avoids the question because he doesn't to hurt Natalia's feelings.

I guess I feel bad for Luke at this point because now that he knows he's a replica he seems like an innocent child and even though Guy is his best friend he has all these secrets. Like the revenge plot, and the fact that he "might" have known Van before their homeland was destroyed. (That was in a face chat I saw after staying in Tear's room and I don't know if enters into the main story).

Ah, but I think it's good to have all these questions because it keeps the game interesting!